Back to KerryTech

Joint Default Probability

Exploring the relationship between borrower PD, asset correlation and the probability that two borrowers default together.

The Two-Borrower Default Problem

Two borrowers can each have a relatively low probability of default, but their probability of defaulting together can be materially higher when their underlying economic risks are correlated.

This calculator uses a one-factor Gaussian asset-value model. The joint default probability is calculated from the bivariate normal distribution using a tetrachoric (Hermite) series expansion.

30.0%
Basel correlation assumption

When selected, the asset correlation is calculated from the borrower PDs using the standard Basel corporate exposure correlation relationship.

For two borrowers with different PDs, the two Basel-implied correlations are averaged to obtain a single correlation parameter for the bivariate model.

R(PD) = 0.12 x [1 - exp(-50 x PD)] / [1 - exp(-50)] + 0.24 x [1 - [1 - exp(-50 x PD)] / [1 - exp(-50)]]

Results

Borrower 1 PD
2.00%
Borrower 2 PD
2.00%
Joint Default Probability
0.0000%
Default Correlation
0.00%

If the borrowers were independent

0.0400%

Independent JDP = PD1 x PD2.

Excess joint-default probability

0.0000%

Additional joint-default probability caused by positive dependence.

Tetrachoric series: Calculating...

From Asset Correlation to Joint Default

The model assumes that each borrower's latent asset value is driven by a common systematic factor plus an idiosyncratic factor.

X1 = sqrt(rho) x M + sqrt(1-rho) x e1 X2 = sqrt(rho) x M + sqrt(1-rho) x e2

The borrower defaults when its latent asset value falls below the threshold corresponding to its probability of default.

a = Phi^-1(PD1) b = Phi^-1(PD2)

The bivariate normal CDF can then be expressed using the tetrachoric, or Hermite, series:

Phi2(a,b,rho) = Phi(a) x Phi(b) + phi(a) x phi(b) x SUM [ rho^n / n! x H(n-1,a) x H(n-1,b) ] for n = 1 to infinity

The first term is particularly useful from a credit-risk perspective. It is simply the joint default probability that would exist if the borrowers were independent. The remaining terms represent the incremental effect of correlation.

Why Default Correlation Is Different

Asset correlation describes the relationship between the underlying continuous asset values. Default correlation describes the relationship between the two binary default events. They are therefore not the same quantity.

Default correlation = [JDP - PD1 x PD2] / sqrt[ PD1 x (1-PD1) x PD2 x (1-PD2) ]

The transformation from asset correlation to default correlation depends strongly on the two PDs. This is one reason why relatively modest asset correlation can produce significant default dependence for low-PD borrowers.

Visualising Default Dependence

Joint Default Probability vs Asset Correlation
Default Correlation vs Asset Correlation
Maximum Default Correlation Implied by PD

Maximum Possible Default Correlation

Default is a binary event, so there is a mathematical limit to the possible correlation between two default indicators. For two borrowers with equal PD, perfect positive dependence allows every default by one borrower to coincide with a default by the other, giving a maximum default correlation of 100%. When the PDs differ, the maximum possible correlation can be lower.

Maximum joint probability = min(PD1, PD2) Maximum default correlation = [min(PD1,PD2) - PD1 x PD2] / sqrt[ PD1 x (1-PD1) x PD2 x (1-PD2) ]
Important: This calculator is an educational implementation of the Gaussian asset-value approach. The Basel correlation relationship shown here is an input assumption from the Basel capital framework. It is not itself a Basel capital requirement or capital calculation.